Wednesday, March 06, 2013
  The Linguistic Literalism of Four-Year Olds

The Linguistic Literalism of Four-Year Olds
(Part Three of a Three-part series)
By Pamela Taylor

Have you ever given directions to a four-year old? 

“Go to the end of the hall and turn left,” you say. 

“Is this left?” he asks, holding up his left hand. 

“Right!” you say cheerily. 

He then lowers his left hand and puts up his right hand.

“Oh,” he says, “Then I have to turn this way.”

“No, no.  That’s your right hand,” you say.  “The other one was your left hand.”

The poor kid is now totally confused.  His mind, focused on left and right, didn’t grasp the changed context of your initial response; he missed that you had switched from right/left to correct/incorrect, or, in other words, right/wrong.

I experienced a similar e-mail exchange the other day on a news groups I belong to.  One poster forwarded several hadith (thank God their source were at least cited!):

1)      The Prophet (SAW) said: “The hanging of clothes below the ankles in pride is forbidden.” (Bukhari)

2)       Hazrat Abu Hurairah (RA) relates that Rasulullah (SAW) said: “On the Day of Judgement Allah will not look at the one who lets his trousers down out of pride.” (Bukhari, Muslim)

3)      Hazrat Abu Zarr (RA) said: “Such persons as are doomed, who are they Oh Messenger of Allah?”

Nabi (SAW) replied: “One who lets out his apparels out of arrogance, one who reminds or makes a show of favors done by him to another, and one who sells his (inferior) wares with false oaths.” Another version of Muslim adds: “One who lets down his pyjama or loin cloth.”

He concluded with the pronouncement that “The covering of ankles (for men) is Haraam and a major sin.  The Holy Prophet (Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam) clearly stresses the importance of keeping the trousers above the ankles!  Let us Pray Allah gives us strength to enact His Commands!”

Like the four-year old, this poster neglected to notice that the context has changed since the time of the Prophet.  Wearing trousers that extend past one’s ankles is no longer a sign of arrogance.  Wearing Armani suits or platinum rings with four-karat diamonds is.  Indeed, a man wearing pants that didn’t reach the ankle would likely be considered slightly odd, or perhaps effeminate, since his pants would closely approximate the Capri pants that are so popular with women these days.  When I pointed this out, and that the purpose of the hadiths was to remind us not to be arrogant, even in our dress, a protracted storm of debate arose about how long the pants could be, whether grazing the tops of the ankle bones was ok, or if the hem needed to be several inches over the ankle, whether socks and snow boots violated this command, and so on.  

And, of course, several people lectured me about how even if you understand the metaphorical meaning you can’t throw out the literal one, which struck me as a really odd response since saying these hadiths are about arrogance, not inches of cloth, has nothing to do with metaphor.  It’s a rather direct interpretation of the hadiths, just not one that insists on maintaining the old context.  (Indeed, I’m not sure what metaphorical meaning one might make out of these hadith…hmm… Pants are a metaphor for legs, so we all have to shorten our legs… Yowza!  Tall people are doomed!)

This kind of wrong-context interpretation, this myopic focus on literalism as opposed to concern for the intent, for the wisdom behind a given hadith or Qur’anic statement, has become the norm for our ummah.  That old adage that we can’t see the forest for the trees is all too fitting.  As a result we have entrenched ourselves in an ossified version of Islam that is rigid, inflexible, unfit for the current context, and all in all rather unappealing.  Small wonder that we are perceived as backwards, and different, unable to fit into modern society.  In reality, we are choosing by the busload not to fit into modern society.

In doing so, we not only make Islam difficult for ourselves (It is not easy being a social outcast, nor to straightjacket one’s life with a thousand picayune and demanding rules!) but we are apt to miss the point of the religion altogether.  Islam according to the Qur’an is supposed to easy.  It is designed to help a person reach their full potential as a good creature, as a blessing to this world and to his or her own self.  Focusing the literal meaning as opposed to the general principle more often than not works opposite to those inclinations.  It focuses us upon details rather than the spirit of the law and, taken to the extreme that is has been in recent years, results in spiritual decay rather than spiritual development.  It focuses us in upon our own deeds, rather than outward upon making the world a better place.  It wastes unimaginable volumes of energy and time as we try to discern each and every rule to follow, debating back and forth with our co-religionists as to which interpretation is the most valid.

Furthermore, an Islam based upon literalism fails to meet some of the most basic spiritual needs of humanity. It leaves no room for a personal relationship with God, demanding that everyone be a cookie-cutter copy of The Model – a detailed and exacting model.  It leaves us confused and with inappropriate responses to our situation, just as the four-year old remains confused about whether this hand or that is the left one and unsure of which direction he should turn.  Small wonder, yet again, that we are not the moral and spiritual leaders of the world.  What is astonishing is that we think, with the ummah by and large practicing such a literal level of interpretation, that we should be such leaders!

One can’t help but wonder how it came to be that the ummah got stuck at the linguistic and interpretive level of a four-year old.   How and when we did we allow ourselves to slip into intellectual imprecision and moral immaturity?  And how and when we are going to grow up, how we will learn to think like adults and take the place in the world that we should.
Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home

My Photo
Location: Cincinnati, Ohio, United States

Progressive Muslim, feminist, mom, writer, mystic, lover of the universe and Doug Schmidt, cellist, theologian and imam.

What I'm reading now

Cane River
An interesting exploration of the gradual whiting of a family through slavery to modern days.

To see an archive of all the books I've read (well the ones I've read and review since I started the blog) with comments, please click here

Causes Worth Supporting

This is just a short list -- a few of my favorites.

English Language Islamic Fiction. We need more of it. Lots more.
Pay a Teacher's Salary in Afghanistan. The Hunger site actually has a lot of worthwhile programs. You can find them all here .
Muslims for Progressive Values. My organization. We can always use donations, of time or money!
Human Rights Campaign for the glbt community
National Religious Campaign Against Torture
The ACLU I'm a card carrying member. Hope you'll become one too. The organization that has done the most, as far as I can tell, to pull the countries progressive side together.
Network of Spiritual Progressives. Working to reclaim religion and morality for the religious left.

Blogs Worth Reading

Wanda Campbell also known as Nochipa A very gifted poet and a gentle, compassionate soul. Nochipa and I are on the same page on sooooo many things
Writeous Sister Aminah Hernandez, she's got some excellent latino pieces and always has good writing info on her blog.
Sister Scorpion aka Leila Montour - Leila is a fount of energy, quirky humor, and bad attitude. She's also a talented poet.
Muhajabah Very interesting commentary here. I don't always agree with her, but her pieces are always thought-provoking.
Georgie Dowdell Georgie is a great writer and a good friend.
Louise Marley Another great writer. I think Louise is one of the best sf writers exploring faith themes.
Ink in My Coffee Devon Ellington (who has numerous aliases) who is also the editor of Circadian Poems. A truly inspiring woman with a seemingly endless supply of energy.
Ethnically Incorrect With a name like that, isn't a given I'm going to enjoy this writer?
Freedom from the Mundane Colin Galbraith, another excellent writer, from Scotland.
The Scruffy Dog Review This is a new e-zine with an ecclectic mix of fiction, poetry, and non-fic, some really enjoyable pieces here.
Ramblings of a Suburban Soccer Mom Lara, another gentle soul, very thoughtful.
Circadian Poems A journal of poetry, new stuff up all the time.
Ye Olde Inkwell Michelle writes romance and is one of my writing buddies.
Muhammad Michael Knight The original punk Muslim writer. Like him or love him, Mike is always coming up with the unexpected.

Recent Posts

October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
July 2006
August 2006
September 2006
October 2006
November 2006
December 2006
January 2007
February 2007
March 2007
April 2007
May 2007
June 2007
July 2007
August 2007
September 2007
October 2007
November 2007
December 2007
January 2008
February 2008
July 2008
December 2008
January 2009
February 2009
March 2009
April 2009
May 2009
June 2009
July 2009
February 2013
March 2013
April 2013
July 2013